DHCR Reaffirms That Rent Concessions Are Not Preferential Rents, Undercutting the Foundation of Grey v. LIC Development Owner and Choi v. Linc LIC
The New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) has updated its guidance on Fact Sheet #40, confirming that a temporary agreement not to collect rent can be a lawful rent concession rather than a “preferential rent,” and that its 2019 revision of Fact Sheet #40 never meant otherwise. That clarification strikes at the reasoning of the Appellate Division, First Department in Grey v. LIC Development Owner, L.P., 2025-04182, 2025-05334 (1st Dept Mar. 17, 2026), and Choi v. Linc LIC L.L.C., 2026 NY Slip Op 02919 (1st Dept May 12, 2026). Belkin Burden Goldman LLP represents the owner in both cases.
What DHCR Said
As we argued in Grey and Choi, DHCR never intended to treat all concessions as preferential rents, and the HSTPA did not change the definition of “preferential rent.” DHCR’s updated guidance states:
“Both DHCR and New York State courts have long recognized that, under certain circumstances, a temporary agreement not to pay rent for a portion of time may be considered a rent concession and not create a preferential rent. Accordingly, DHCR continues to recognize that there are distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents, and DHCR’s 2019 modification of Fact Sheet #40 was not intended to indicate the contrary. Whether any such temporary agreement is in fact a rent concession should be based on the specific facts and circumstances presented at the time of the agreement.”
This rejects the Appellate Division decisions which held any rent concession is per se illegal regardless of the reason based upon the Appellate Division’s interpretation of what DHCR intended when issuing its 2019 Fact Sheet #40. This updated guidance makes crystal clear that every rent concession requires an analysis of the facts and circumstances including “but not limited to, the circumstances giving rise to the temporary abatement, including physical conditions affecting the property or other circumstances affecting residential occupancy, the duration and temporary nature of the abatement, and a review of the actual language of the agreement”.
Why the DHCR Guidance Matters
The post-HSTPA holdings in Grey and Choi assume that DHCR’s 2019 revision of Fact Sheet #40 eliminated the concession/preferential rent distinction. DHCR now says the opposite: the revision “was not intended to indicate the contrary,” and DHCR “continues to recognize that there are distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents.”
The First Department has credited Fact Sheet #40 “as a valid interpretation of the law” (Flynn v Red Apple 670 Pac. St., LLC, 200 AD3d 607, 609 [1st Dept 2021], cited in Grey). Owners now have a strong basis to argue that Grey and Choi misread agency guidance, that their post-HSTPA concession holdings should be limited or reconsidered, and that post-HSTPA concessions should be judged under DHCR’s facts-and-circumstances test.
What Owners Should Do Now
- Review existing concession agreements and lease riders. Check that the language describes a temporary abatement tied to specific circumstances, not a reduced legal regulated rent.
- Document the reasons for each concession, such as market conditions, building conditions, construction, or other factors affecting occupancy.
- Reassess pending and threatened overcharge claims based on post-HSTPA concessions for new or renewed defenses under the DHCR guidance.
- Consult counsel before using early occupancy or license structures that purport to exempt occupancy from rent stabilization.
How We Can Help
Belkin Burden Goldman LLP has represented New York building owners in rent regulation matters for decades, including in Grey and Choi. For questions about how this guidance affects your portfolio or pending litigation, please contact:
Jeffrey L. Goldman, Co-Managing Partner / Chair, Litigation Department
(212) 867-4466 | jgoldman@bbgllp.com
Matthew S. Brett
(212) 867-4466 | mbrett@bbgllp.com