Litigation Partner Matthew S. Brett Discusses Major DHCR Rent-Concession Guidance with The Real Deal
Belkin Burden Goldman, LLP Litigation Partner Matthew S. Brett was quoted in The Real Deal regarding updated guidance from the New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) clarifying the distinction between rent concessions and preferential rents. Matt has represented landlords in a number of 421-a rent-concession cases that have reached the state’s appellate court.
The revised Fact Sheet 40 comes amid a wave of rent-overcharge lawsuits challenging concessions offered by owners of rent-stabilized apartments. DHCR’s updated
language states that the agency continues to recognize distinctions between rent concessions and preferential rents and that its 2019 revision was not intended to suggest otherwise.
Matt called the update a “significant development.”
“The agency has now said plainly that it continues to recognize a distinction between rent concessions and preferential rents, and that its 2019 revision was never intended to suggest otherwise,” Matt said. “Whether a concession is a preferential rent depends on the specific facts and circumstances when the lease was signed, such as conditions at the building, what was happening with occupancy, and how long the concession lasted.”
Matt also addressed the impact of the updated guidance on litigation following the Grey decision, a case in which BBG represents the landlord. He explained that many subsequently filed lawsuits assumed that every post-HSTPA concession automatically constituted a preferential rent, without making specific allegations about the circumstances surrounding the concessions. Ultimately, Matt emphasized that the analysis remains fact-specific: “There is no one-size-fits-all rule.”
Read the full The Real Deal article, “A Tiny Housing Rule Change Could Mean NYC Landlords Save Hundreds of Millions,” here.
BBG also recently published an advisory examining DHCR’s updated guidance and its implications for owners of rent-stabilized properties. Read our advisory: “DHCR Clarifies Rules on Rent Concessions for Rent-Stabilized Apartments”.

